Sunoasis Jobs! Classifieds
Writers Notebook
Some Impressions on the War on Terrorism

Dissent is one thing that keeps free people honest. It's not that the dissenters are always honest. Many times their motives are suspect. But, the ability to contradict the official message and do so with intelligence and imagination ensures that the official message has to account for its own shadows. In the case with Iraq those shadows would include the bloody aftermath, the unclear picture of what our intention in Iraq truly is, the use of insider companies to build Iraq and their own bottom-lines through taxpayer money, among other shadows of the policy.

The dissent won't get too far as long as people are convinced the threat of terror is immanent. And who is to tell them that it is not? And who can be trusted with such information?

It appears an open-ended question with one bottom-line fact: People who hate, who are willing to sacrifice themselves, and who have access or want access to very dangerous weapons need to be paid attention to. And the mad among them visualize a total collapse to the global system. It would create the sort of vacuum that initiated the rise of Islam a few hundred years after the fall of Rome. And the fact that two fallen buildings could wreak the havoc it did on the economy is very sobering. The new wars will be conducted against the economies of the world and not the military.

Whether rag-tag soldiers can pull it off is another question. The attack on New York and the Pentagon needed years of planning, utmost secrecy, and the element of surprise. The ability to do it again with the world watching is very difficult to imagine. Limited, even deadly attacks such as what is happening in Iraq now, may be more likely.

We need to revivify the notion of self-determination.

This is another way of saying that it's up to the American people to understand the world with a great deal more precision. An inexperienced and ignorant people have a caricatured view of another nation. In fact, the inexperienced and ignorant people of the world can come up with a very distorted view of the United States. We are strong enough to accept it and quickly pass it out of our lower extremities.

However, our views of the individual countries in Africa or the Middle-east or Asia can be just as distorted. And those views can make their way into policy or non-policy.

We have one successful model for the maintenance of a huge, nation-state system. It consists of a strong federalism, anchored by a Constitution that most people have respect and loyalty for. But, the strength of the U.S. is the distinctive regions that have access to the strength of all other regions. Silicon Valley may be in northern California and help define that region but it is a boon to Nebraska, Florida, and South Carolina as well.

Is it fair, then, to expect other countries that are less resourceful, to come up to the level of the United States? I believe it is not fair and we need to account for a lot of the differences before making judgements about other parts of the world. We live in a privileged nation that is always balanced by its shadows like poverty. It is not a perfect nation but one that advances on its own leverages in ways that are astounding. It's true that some of the obsessions of the free Americans seem very paltry, even evidence of a corrupted spirit and the acts and celebrations of other parts of the world seem utterly rooted to actual human experience through the ages. The American model is a structural one in which the people, generally, have not caught up with the advancement. Blubbery self-congratulations and drunken grins in sweet-smelling city streets aren't much of an advance in the cause of freedom.

And one question lingers in the air, very general but one close to a thinking man's heart: Has America exhausted its freedoms? Is this all there is? Where are the new, authentic freedoms? That is the place the real American spirit heads for, not the simple keeping of the status quo which belongs to the old world.

Posted January 12, 2004

I invite comments on this column. Use the convenient form below and thanks!

E-Mail Address:

Write your comments here:

Go back to War back to War on Terrorism

Back to Events

Back to Media Resource page

Back to Media Resource page

David Eide
copyright 2003
March 27, 2003